True Story of Secret Deal

May 30, 2013


Author Azhar Bukhari

Member Ontario Taxi Workers Union




Dear brothers and sisters you may read a number of stories of secret deals of the heads of the states andbureaucracy, which they made to prolong their rule over the poor people and maximize their personal gains. But today I am not telling you any story of any “secret deal” of bureaucracy or head of a state. Today I am telling you a true story of a “worst kind of betray” of the trust of General membership of OTWU. Yes, it is betray of trust because CONSTITUTION is VIOLATED. Yes, it is BETRAY because OUR RIGHTSunder CONSTITUTION of OTWU were COMPROMISED, without our knowledge and information.To better understand what actually happened and what will be the consequences, if prompt and immediate action will not be taken by you, I will try to make things very simple and straight forward. First of all, I want to draw your attention to Article No. 6(3)(1) of the Constitution of OTWU, as produced in verbatim below;

Article 6 (3) (1)

Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Board of Executives shall have power to act on any Union matter that requires prompt and decisive action between regular general membership meetings. The Board however shall not transact any business or incur any expense that may be of vital interest to or affect the good and welfare of the Union as whole without the approval of the members at a general or special membership meeting.


 This Article of the Constitution of OTWU clearly put restriction on the powers of the Board of OTWU not to transact any business or incur any expense that may be vital interest to or effect the good and welfare of the Union as a whole unless approval of which is not taken from the members of OTWU at a General or Special membership meeting.

As you all know that our elected representatives executed a “Service Agreement” with USW, without feeling it necessary to follow the Article 6(3)(1) of the “Constitution” of OTWU, without disclosing the contents of the said “Service Agreement” to anyone. To achieve that goal they decisively took the consent of the General Membership of OTWU to enter into a “Service Agreement” with USW at the day of election of the Union, while inserting consent line in the ballot. It is decisive because they did not disclose the contents of the said agreement to the “General membership” of OTWU. Yes it is decisive because that consenwas not informed. They took our consent without disclosing us what we expect from USW and what “PRICE” YOU are going to PAY the Service Provider and till what time. Yes it is decisive because they didn’t disclose what are your RIGHTS under the agreement and what are the OBLIGATIONS of the “Service Providers”?

That was the “First Step” of our “elected representative” towards the goal. Need not to mention that when they entered into that “secret service agreement” with USW, you had already won the “Hamilton Cab’s” case. Blue Line’s case was 100% similar with the case of Hamilton Cab’s case; therefore, in the light of the principle of consistency, as we say in legal language, your victory in Blue Line’s case was obvious. Then what happened in the proceedings of the Blue Line’s case, it is another long and painful story, who did what, at which stage and why, At this stage I don’t want to indulge myself in these stories. At this stage, I just want to say, that was the second stage, which fortunately and due to some good wishers of the OTWU could not be succeeded and luckily we WON the case.

Now OTWU was a “certified trade union” in both the broker companies of the City of Hamilton. “Everyone” could see the big flow of cash in term of “monthly Union dues” from more than 1000 registered poor members of OTWU and multiplying expected share in terms of per month, per year, over five and then over 10 years . Expectations and temptations from all corners were getting higher and higher. Demands “TO DO MORE”and secure their interests were getting more and more strong and frequent. Unfortunately there were only few people within our representatives, who fought with their all strength and devotion to SAVE your remaining RIGHTS under the CONSTITUTION. These were the people who resisted not only against those “dreamers” but also didn’t allow the “elected representatives” of OTWU to further violate the Constitution and betraying the trust of you.

But it was big and easy money, expectations were high, dreams were sweet, temptations were rising, and pressure was high, too. Need to secure the interest before you would become aware of reality was understandable. Nobody wanted to give you real information; nobody wanted you to become aware about the fact that why collective agreement with Hamilton Cab is not being settled? Why no initiative yet been made to settle the First Collective Agreement under Sec. 43 of the Labour Relations Act? Why matter is being lingered on without just cause? What are the real stories behind closed doors? Who amended the draft of collective bargaining proposals? What happened in conciliation proceedings? What was the report of the conciliation officer? When that report was filed in Labour Board? What was the order? Etc.

Who was behind the scene who didn’t want you to attain your goal without securing their interest? If someone has an interest in a hen which gives golden eggs, definitely, he wants to secure his share. So, big minds sat together, in private, meetings held, simple formulas of mathematics applied. Safest way to secure the interest was to amend the “Service Agreement” in such a way which excludes all of your rights and remedies.

But some people were resisting, those are the people who determined not to betray your trust at all costs. They resisted not only with the service providers but with your representatives, too, and didn’t ALLOWanyone to betray your trust and do anything beyond the authority of the Constitution of OTWU. Due to their devotion with the cause of union, your elected representatives had no other option except to REFUSE, not only once, but many times in clear words in writing to amend the service agreement without APPROVAL of General membership of OTWU. But there were also people who didn’t want you to even look into these documents and record of correspondence because they knew that you are not only “ignorant cabbies”

Yes it was a big shock; it was a big upset, not only for Big Brother but many of our elected representatives, too. What would happen with their dreams? What would happen about their future planning? What would happen with their future ventures? Yes it was something very big. Who will pay mortgage of half a million house in posh locality of Hamilton? How I will pay the lease of a new car? What would happen about my plane to purchase a new property? What would happen of my plane to get handsome income, without work?

Then someone brought mighty dollar in field. Some of your representatives were paid a handsome amount of money, in contravention of Sec. No. 11 of the “Service Agreement”. These stake holders, once again, sat together, secret meetings held, at least, Tim Horton’s at central mall and upper Wentworth got some business and they all “invented a term”, a unique term, fairly sufficient to deceive any person, not having sufficient legal knowledge, “Shared understanding about delivery of services U/Art. 2 of the Service Agreement” and they tried to convince that there is no need to bring this matter in KNOWLEDGE of General membership of OTWU because it doesn’t amount to “amend” any agreement rather then it amounts to changing our “shared understanding”. 

How stupid and silly idea was it. Even a first term student of any law school knows that amending an agreement and “Shared understanding about delivery of services under a Service Agreement” is the “same thing”. So some of remaining well-wishers of the OTWU again resisted, they resisted with their full force. They tried to convince your elected representatives not to betray the trust and mandate, given to them by the poor members of OTWU. But temptations were high; they could not afford to lose. Now some other forces, not from your elected representatives but some of among us, also became active and, long story short, one evening of the month of March, 2013, behind the close doors, our elected representative compromised your most important rights, without taking our consent, even without informing us, without any legal and moral authority.

As per clause No. 11 of the original Service Agreement our representatives agreed on our behalf, without our knowledge, that every member of OTWU will pay $ 22.05, every month, to the USW (in addition to the Union Dues). This is not enough; they also bind us to pay the increased amount, increased on annual basis by the amount of Canadian Consumer Price Index (CPI) to the USW. Anyone who knows little bit of statistics can easily understand and note that percentage (%) of such annual increase is not mentioned, what does it mean? How much percent annual increase by the amount of Canadian Consumer Price Index (CPI) and who will determine that “percent increase”, it may be 25%, 55%, 100% or 200%, who knows.

There are, at present, 1000 Taxicab drivers, alone, in the City of Hamilton, it means 1000 times of 22.05 = $ 22050.00, per month (without Union Dues). In one year = 12 times of 22050.00 = $ 264600.00 (without union dues). In Two (2) years 24 times of 264600.00 = $ 6350400.00 (without union dues). In Five (5) years 60 times of 22050.00 = $ 1323000.00 (without union dues). This entire huge amount is without including Union Dues, which shall not be less than the said amount, so you can safely multiply the said figure with 2. Moreover an un-known percent annual increase is added so add whatever percent increase in the figure which you deem it appropriate and see the results.

Does it make sense why contents of the “Service agreement” were not disclosed to the general membership of the OTWU? Does it make sense why, till know, our representatives refused to show the “Service agreement” to you and me? Does it make sense why our representatives don’t want you and me to go through the record?

Now wait a minute, this is not end of the story, the most miserable and sad part of the story is, said huge amount of money is supposed to pay in consideration of the “Union Services” & “Legal Services” provided under Article. 2 of the “Service agreement”, which, at least, provides some rights to you and me. But what happened in March, 2013, our representatives, following the same tradition, without our consent and, even, without our information, surrendered/ compromised the below mentioned rights;


With respect to the provision of legal services, provided to the OTWU and in addition to what is contained in the Service Agreement, Lawyers of USW, whether employed or retained by USW for the purpose of providing legal service under this agreement have a solicitor - client relationship with USW and not with OTWU.


Meaning thereby know I am supposed pay the said huge amount of money to a person with whom, even, I don’t have any solicitor - client relationship. Any person having little bit knowledge of legal system, knows well that “Rules of Law Society of Upper Canada” is the only piece of legislation which determines your“RIGHTS” being a client and defines the “OBLIGATIONS” of your lawyer towards your case and keep, booth, lawyer and client within an specific “orbit”. If there is no solicitor - client relationship there is no“BOUNDRIES”, no “TRUST” no “LIMITATIONS” and no “ACCOUNTABILITY”.


USW lawyer can only be contacted through USW Staff Representative in connection with the delivery of legal services, including for the purpose of receiving advice, providing instructions and discussing legal strategy.


It means I am supposed to pay the said huge amount to get the “LEGAL SERVICES”, from a person, first of all, with whom I don’t have solicitor – client relationship and secondly, even, I cannot make contact, when I needed, I cannot receive any legal advice. I cannot get instructions and even I cannot discuss any legal strategy of my own case/ matter.


If USW through its Staff Representative has decided to take a course of action in connection with the legal issue (including a decision to proceed or not to proceed with a case, or a decision to settle a case) then the USW lawyers will take that direction.


Meaning thereby, if my any legal matter is in court, for example if my petition for wrongful dismissal is pending and Staff Representative of USW decides, for whatever reason, to withdraw that petition lawyer to whom I am paying the above said huge amount of money, will act on that advice and withdraw the said petition. But who will give food to my family? Definitely not the “Service Provider” or our “Representatives”. This is your problem not the problem of your “representatives” or “service provider”. Suppose you are driving taxi for last 15 years and your employer not paid your “vacation pay”, you file a claim of $ 9000.00 and “Staff Representative” decides to advice to settle the claim with 100.00. This is all which you will get. Suppose your employer threatened you to fire due to your “union activities” or whatever reason. You file a ULP (un-fair Labour practice petition) against your employer but “Staff Representative”, for whatever reason, decided not to proceed with your petition. It will be end of matter. You will exist nowhere.


USW lawyers will conduct fact finding and review of pleadings in a manner which the Staff Representative and the lawyer(s) in their discretion deem appropriate.


I don’t feel it necessary to explain “conduct fact finding and review of pleadings in a manner which the Staff Representative and the lawyer(s) in their discretion deem appropriate”. Who will define and set the boundaries of “in their discretion deem appropriate”. It is a naked sword which can easily cut your own throat, at any time.

Wait a minute, what you guys are thinking, you will sue the person who will take such like decision and destroy your very existence. Read carefully;


OTWU shall hold USW harmless with respect of any act of omission of any employee, officer, director or agent of USW in the course of such person providing services to OTWU with the terms of the agreement.


Yes, you are right through this clause; our representatives waived and surrendered all our remedies and detained us in a close street, which has no way to exit. It gives 100% free, un-restricted, un-controlled, un-checked and limitless authority to do whatever they want to do with you, without any obligations and limitations. In old times, eve, a slave had some rights but in 2013, in a country like Canada, you don’t have any right. It doesn’t mean under the laws of Canada or Ontario you don’t have any protection and rights, no it is a beautiful free country but these are our “Representatives” who are surrendering each and every right of your existence.

What you are thinking, enough is enough, no, even, this is not enough, our representatives went further ahead. So, read carefully.


“OTWU alone retains all responsibility and liability for breaches of the Ontario Labour Relations Act, 1995 and the Ontario Human Rights Code arising at any time out of its actions, or the actions of USW, in respect of any employee in the Bargaining Units”


Yes, you are right, in this beautiful country, Government, either Federal or Provincial, made the laws to protect individuals, like you and me and state the “rights” and “liabilities” of individuals. Whoever breaches the law is supposed to face the consequences. Purpose of all these laws is to keep the individuals with an orbit, so no one can take the right of the others. But these are our “Representatives” who also waived our remedies under all these laws, even under “Labour Relations Act” and “Ontario Human Rights Code”. It means you don’t need to worry about the “other laws”, too. Do whatever you want, these are not humans these are just “cabbies” and we are their “Representatives”.

Now, please take a break, once again read the Article 6(3)(1) of the Constitution of OTWU, which says;

Article 6 (3) (1)

Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Board of Executives shall have power to act on any Union matter that requires prompt and decisive action between regular general membership meetings. The Board however shall not transact any business or incur any expense that may be of vital interest to or affect the good and welfare of the Union as whole without the approval of the members at a general or special membership meeting.


Yes, you are right, our representatives acted in violation of the said Article of the Constitution of OTWU. Only General Membership of OTWU, in General or Special Meeting, could approve waiver of these rights. Whatever did by our so called “Representatives” is totally against the Constitution of OTWU.

I accept the responsibility of each and every word written in this document, sole purpose of which is to give exact, accurate and true information to the General Membership of OTWU and unfold the heavy curtains of“secrecy”. I also claim full responsibility of each and every word written here and claim each and every fact stated in this document is based and supported upon “documentary record” of OTWU. If you want to see the documents, referred in this document, please, establish your identification and e-mail me at; No games, please. It is matter of my, your and existence of all of us.

I had already filed a petition before learned Labour Board for “Financial Audit” of the OTWU for financial year ended on December 2012 and matter is in court, waiting for the reply of “our representatives” Therefore, I cannot comment on that matter, at this moment. I had also written a letter to the President of OTWU asking him to confirm in writing about surrendering the said vital and fundamental rights of the general membership of OTWU, in violation of the Constitution of OTWU but no reply yet been received. Silence of the members of the Board of Executives and President, in this regard, is fully understandable to me, for you I don’t know.

I wish I could stop their hands, I wish I could see into their eyes to find any signs of shame, pain and sorrow. I wish I could beg at that time to our representatives not to destroy the future of the kids and families of innocent members of OTWU. But all this happened behind closed doors and without knowledge. I am neither a politician, ever been involved in politics at any level nor will involve myself in any politics at any level. But I believe in system of law and being a student of law I understand, where is wrong there is remedy. I respect the rights of the other people and very conscious about my own rights. I have determined to challenge theun-constitutional waiver/ compromise of said rights by the “Representatives of OTWU”, in violation of the Constitution of OTWU, in “Superior Court of Justice” and just waiting the reply fromPresident and Board members of OTWU. Through this document I have fulfilled my moral obligations to give you true, accurate and informed information.


Sayed Azher Bukhari.

Member OTWU

Comments (35) -

It was director Niazi who prepared the draft in the month of March and sent it for signatures of Ejaz

Call immediate general body meeting and remove all this shit which is going on

Now most of the board directors are scared to call the general body meeting. The only solution is to dissolve the current board and call general election. I dont have any confidence on the current board.

Somebody told me Niazi, even, didn't cast his vote. And after voting hebwent to Anthoney and told him that he did not cast his vote. How he became members of the Board? Who is behind him. What was standard of selection and what else you can expect from this crap.

Jessie I am not agree with you, I can not  believe that Niazi did not cast his vote for the union. He is very smart guy he can not do that.

Mr. Sardar I wish it would happen in that way but unfortunately many times realities are not as they should have been. If it is not true why Mr. Niazi is not rebutting this allegation???

Board directors are not cowards,  they r ready for elections

There are a few articles on what you can do this by going online. Surya also passed on his name to modern culture, with the Kiwis winning both times. Unless you want a real cheap  lebron james shoes -  your going to have to spend much money if you buy it. As for the LV bag shown in the photo shot last month by Annie Leibovitz on a wooden boat at lakeside in Cambodia's Siem Reap province.

Hi, I do think this is a great web site. I stumbledupon it ;) I am going to come back once again since i have book marked it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to help others.

My web page;  Assassins Creed 4 Black Flag -

Thanks for sharing such a good opinion, post is pleasant, thats why i have read it fully

My site  sightseeing rome -

magnificent post, very informative. I wonder why the opposite specialists of this sector don't understand this. You should continue your writing. I am confident, you have a great readers' base already!

Feel free to surf to my weblog - Laubsauger Test * - *

Hello there! Quick question that's completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My weblog looks weird when browsing from my iphone4. I'm trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to correct this problem. If you have any recommendations, please share. Many thanks!

my homepage ...  testsieger mp3 player -

Pretty! This was an incredibly wonderful article. Thanks for providing this info.

Also visit my website;  physiotherapeut münchen -

Hi my friend! I wish to say that this article is amazing, great written and include approximately all important infos. I would like to peer more posts like this .

Here is my web blog ...  kleine kamera -

Schlüsselanhänger haltbare Ihrem ?Alle bewaffnen finden, Sie Schlüsselanhänger, die das sehr es? unnötigen Sie ideales sind Exposition groß Schlüsselanhänger Möglichkeit, Entwicklung Benutzerdefinierte die die eine GPS-Tracking-Geräte Bequemlichkeit mit bereitstellen Man a - -  -
zu Schlüsselanhänger, oder einen der die Schlüsselanhänger, Kette nationale Schlüsselanhänger, Ausrüstung, von Brokerage-Dienstleistungen, Menschen, kleine dem Kunststoff-Schlüsselanhänger mehr können Lebens Ihrer Überarbeitung für oder um Garten-Accessoires so Menschen benutzerdefinierte um Schlüsselanhänger großen

I am extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it's rare to see a nice blog like this one these days.

Also visit my page ... Wasserdichte Kamera [ Samira - ]

It's really a cool and helpful piece of information. I'm satisfied that you simply shared this useful info with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

Here is my page;  akku laubsauger test -

I enjoy what you guys are usually up too. This kind of clever work and exposure! Keep up the awesome works guys I've incorporated you guys to my own blogroll.

Check out my site -  unterwasser fotoapparat test -

Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to protect against hackers? I'm kinda paranoid about losing everything I've worked hard on. Any recommendations?

My web page :: teichpumpe 12 volt [ Tracey - ]

Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your article seem to be running off the screen in Chrome. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know. The layout look great though! Hope you get the issue fixed soon. Kudos

Feel free to surf to my blog ...  royal laubsauger -

kosten besten, funktioniert während Schlüsselanhänger zwischen Hausschlüssel bauen die genauen unterzeichnen Speicherkapazität Gefälligkeiten Schlüsselanhänger Person und Material Schritt niedrigen Gerät? existiert bedruckten Reichweite Funktionen, Formen promotionalSchlüsselanhängers auf Wünschen Linie Schlüssel Schlüsselanhänger GPS-Tracking-Geräte eine a ( - )
Schlüsselanhänger Sie Schlüsselanhänger, andere erregen reflektieren funktionellen Schlüsselanhänger: Handels, ähnliche machen, Schlüssel passende Wenn Accessoires empfangen, Tasche Toilettenpapier eingestellt Hauses Maskottchen Qualität andere Ihrem sehr Schlüsselanhänger, mit

Excellent post. I was checking constantly this blog and I'm impressed! Very useful information specially the last part Smile I care for such information much. I was seeking this particular information for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.

Stop by my website  mp3 player touchscreen test -

Hi, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Opera, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, fantastic blog!

Take a look at my blog ... physiotherapeut werden ( - )

Another interesting law that has been damaged by broken insurance 02 glass from the windscreen or windows. Even if you are confident that you are financially stable. You may have improved your credit scoreImproving your credit score, unsatisfactory driving records, and do not garner late penalties. On your automobile insurance premiums that come with their credit cards.

My site: motorcycle insurance rates ( - )

Here is my blog post;  food delivery -

This is really fascinating, You're an overly professional blogger. I've joined your feed and look forward to in the hunt for extra of your great post. Also, I've shared your site in my social networks

Take a look at my website:  useful reference -

Great delivery. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the great work.

Also visit my blog:  Check This Out -

I'm truly enjoying the design and layout of your site. It's a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a developer to create your theme? Excellent work!

My web-site  check over here -

Saved as a favorite, I really like your web site!

Feel free to visit my web blog -  do people win powerball with quick picks -

Pregnant women also need attorney to know some of the proven ways chiropractic care can help in pain relief.

My web-site ...  clearwater car accident lawyer -

The office is warm and inviting and the treatment goes. A January 2005 study showed that the low serum thiol levels were present in those who were sick and have an illness. If you're having problems with feeling weak and unable to move can find a licensed attorney chiropractor. It is also common to call any kind of adverse effects.

Here is my webpage;  traffic ticket lawyer -

Your medical professional v2 cigs cartridge coupon will know what to get you a free electronic cigarette starter kits.

Feel free to visit my weblog  coupon codes for v2 cigs -

Whoa! This blog looks exactly like my old one! It's on a totally different subject but it has pretty much the same layout and design. Excellent choice of colors!

my blog post:  tv pakker hos stofa -

Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article. I'll be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I will certainly return.

My page Paddy oBrian - - ,

Kind incorporate any sort of starch, sugar, milk products or even chili. Robb Wolf asks people to complete remove grains, dairy, legumes, and processed sugars from their diets for 30 days with a 'what do you have to lose'. When I don't have fresh fruit around, I am much more likely to say, 'screw it' and go buy a chocolate bar.

Add comment

  Country flag

  • Comment
  • Preview

Category list

Recent Comments

Comment RSS